DC04 vs DC05 – Composition, Heat Treatment, Properties, and Applications
Share
Table Of Content
Table Of Content
Introduction
DC04 and DC05 are cold-rolled, low-carbon steel grades commonly specified for sheet applications that demand good formability. Engineers, procurement managers, and manufacturing planners often face a selection dilemma between these grades when balancing forming performance, strength, weldability, surface finish, and cost. Typical decision contexts include choosing material for deep-drawn automotive inner panels (formability prioritized) versus stamped structural components (strength and weldability prioritized).
The principal functional difference between the two grades is the degree to which they are optimized for extreme drawing operations: one grade is specified for very high deep-drawing formability and the other for excellent, but slightly less extreme, forming combined with somewhat higher strength and broader availability. This difference drives choice in tool life, springback control, and process window during high-deformation manufacturing.
1. Standards and Designations
- Common standards where DC04 and DC05 appear:
- EN (European): EN 10130 — Cold rolled low carbon steels — Technical delivery conditions.
- JIS/ASTM/GB: these grades are European designations; equivalent products with similar properties exist under JIS, ASTM, and various national GB designations but names differ.
- ISO: ISO standards reference similar low-carbon cold-rolled qualities.
- Classification:
- Both DC04 and DC05 are low-carbon, non-alloy cold-rolled steels intended for forming. They are not stainless, tool, or HSLA steels.
2. Chemical Composition and Alloying Strategy
| Element | DC04 (typical strategy) | DC05 (typical strategy) |
|---|---|---|
| C | Very low carbon to maximize ductility and reduce martensite risk during forming | Even lower carbon target or tighter control to further enhance deep-drawing capability |
| Mn | Controlled low manganese to balance strength and drawability | Similar low manganese, sometimes slightly lower or more tightly controlled to improve elongation |
| Si | Kept low to maintain formability and surface quality | Low, with attention to prevent embedded oxides that impair drawability |
| P | Closely controlled impurity; kept low to avoid brittleness | Closely controlled and often lower limits to protect deep-drawing performance |
| S | Reduced sulfur or treated (e.g., degassed) to avoid inclusion-induced cracking | Very low sulfur to improve edge stretchability and reduce fracture during deep draws |
| Cr, Ni, Mo, V, Nb, Ti, B | Typically absent or only present in trace amounts; microalloying is minimal | Same approach; microalloying is generally avoided or minimized to preserve excellent formability |
| N | Controlled low nitrogen; high N can reduce ductility | Usually controlled to low levels to protect ductility and deep-drawing performance |
Notes: Exact composition limits are set by the delivery standard and the supplier’s product line. DC05 is formulated and processed to give an improved forming window, achieved primarily through tighter control of carbon, sulfur, phosphorus, and inclusion cleanliness rather than by adding strengthening alloying elements.
How alloying affects properties: - Low carbon reduces the risk of hard, brittle martensite after local work hardening or heating and improves ductility. - Minimal microalloying preserves uniform, soft ferritic microstructure, maximizing drawability. - Reduced sulfur and phosphorus reduce the incidence of edge and surface cracking under severe deformation. - Heavy alloying additions (Cr, Ni, Mo, V, Nb, Ti) are avoided because they increase hardenability and reduce deep-drawing performance.
3. Microstructure and Heat Treatment Response
Typical microstructure: - Both grades are manufactured to produce a clean, fully ferritic microstructure after cold rolling and recrystallization anneal. The microstructure is generally equiaxed ferrite with very low pearlite or carbide fraction.
Response to processing: - Recrystallization anneal (common after cold rolling) produces a fine, homogeneous ferrite grain structure that maximizes ductility and consistent sheet behavior. - Normalizing is not a standard post-process for cold-rolled mild steels intended for deep drawing; it would not be beneficial for these grades. - Quenching and tempering are not applicable: these grades are not designed for hardening or heat-treatment-strengthening routes. - Thermo-mechanical treatments used in upstream hot-rolling and subsequent cold-rolling/annealing control grain size, inclusion morphology, and texture. For DC05, suppliers often apply more stringent control over annealing cycles and cleanliness to improve deep-draw formability and reduce earing.
Effect of processing differences: - Tighter annealing control and cleaner steelmaking for DC05 reduce localized hard zones and inclusion-driven failures, improving the maximum achievable draw ratio and reducing cracking at edges or holes. - DC04, while very formable, may permit a slightly coarser or less strictly controlled microstructure, trading optimal deep-drawing limits for broader availability and lower cost.
4. Mechanical Properties
| Property | DC04 (typical behavior) | DC05 (typical behavior) |
|---|---|---|
| Tensile strength | Moderate; optimized for forming rather than high strength | Slightly lower or similar to DC04, depending on supplier; prioritized for ductility |
| Yield strength | Moderate-low to enable forming without springback | Often marginally lower to reduce springback and facilitate deep draws |
| Elongation (ductility) | High — good for many forming tasks | Higher than DC04 in severe draw conditions; improved uniform elongation |
| Impact toughness | Adequate at ambient; not a primary selection criterion | Similar, with emphasis on avoiding brittle fracture during forming |
| Hardness | Low to support formability and reduce tool wear | Low; emphasis on uniformity to prevent local hard areas |
Explanation: - DC05 is tailored for higher uniform elongation and lower yield limits that facilitate deep-drawing operations and reduce the tendency for cracking during high-strain forming. DC04 offers excellent general deep-drawing performance but provides a slightly higher strength window that can be beneficial where moderate load-bearing or increased stiffness is required. - Neither grade is intended where high hardness or high toughness at low temperatures are primary requirements.
5. Weldability
Weldability considerations revolve around carbon content, total alloying, and hardenability. For qualitative assessment, the commonly used formulas can be placed in context:
-
Carbon equivalent (IIW method) provides an indicator of the tendency to form hard microstructures in the heat-affected zone: $$CE_{IIW} = C + \frac{Mn}{6} + \frac{Cr+Mo+V}{5} + \frac{Ni+Cu}{15}$$
-
A more detailed parameter for predicting cold cracking is the Pcm formula: $$P_{cm} = C + \frac{Si}{30} + \frac{Mn+Cu}{20} + \frac{Cr+Mo+V}{10} + \frac{Ni}{40} + \frac{Nb}{50} + \frac{Ti}{30} + \frac{B}{1000}$$
Interpretation: - Both DC04 and DC05 have very low carbon and minimal alloying, producing low carbon equivalent values and therefore generally excellent weldability by common methods (MIG/MAG, spot welding, resistance welding). - DC05’s tighter chemical control can slightly reduce the propensity for HAZ hardening and cold cracking, benefiting resistance spot welding and full-penetration welds where extreme local deformation follows welding. - Preheat and post-weld heat treatment are generally not required for standard thicknesses, but joint design, restraint, and hydrogen control should follow best welding practice. - For resistance spot welding in automotive assembly, DC05’s improved formability may also deliver more consistent nugget formation in severe-drawing panels.
6. Corrosion and Surface Protection
- Neither DC04 nor DC05 is stainless steel. Corrosion resistance is that of low-carbon mild steel and depends on surface finish and protective coatings.
- Common protections:
- Hot-dip galvanizing (zinc coating) for atmospheric corrosion protection.
- Electro-galvanizing and subsequent organic coatings (e.g., primers, paint) for improved surface appearance and corrosion resistance in automotive and appliance use.
- E-coat, powder coatings, and passivation layers as part of system-level protection.
- PREN (pitting resistance equivalent number) is not applicable to plain low-carbon steels; it is used for stainless alloys: $$\text{PREN} = \text{Cr} + 3.3 \times \text{Mo} + 16 \times \text{N}$$
- Choice of surface treatment must consider forming: coatings must be compatible with deep drawing and avoid flaking, cracking, or affecting lubrication. DC05’s surface cleanliness and coating compatibility are often specified for high-deformation coated product forms.
7. Fabrication, Machinability, and Formability
- Cutting: Both grades machine similarly to other mild steels; blade wear is low. Because DC05 is optimized for forming, burr formation and edge fracturing during shearing and trimming are reduced if processed per supplier guidance.
- Bending/forming: DC05 provides a larger safe process window for severe bending, deep drawing, and ironing: lower springback, better edge stretchability, and reduced earing tendencies. DC04 is excellent for general deep drawing and bending but may be marginal in processes pushing maximum draw ratios.
- Finishing: Surface quality—cleanliness, low oxide scale, and controlled roughness—matters more for DC05 when targeting ultra-deep drawing and tight cosmetic tolerances. Lubrication and blank geometry that account for the enhanced drawability of DC05 can enable thinner gauges and longer tool life.
- Punching/nibbling: DC05’s lower inclusion content reduces the risk of micro-cracking at cut edges under subsequent forming.
8. Typical Applications
| DC04 — Typical Uses | DC05 — Typical Uses |
|---|---|
| General-purpose deep-drawn components: appliance panels, moderate-complexity automotive inner panels, body panels where forming is important but not extreme | Ultra-deep-drawn components and high-complexity formed parts: complex automotive inner assemblies, high-draw appliance bowls, housings requiring extreme formability and minimal springback |
| Stamped structural parts with moderate forming demands | Parts requiring very high uniform elongation and minimal earing in subsequent drawing stages |
| Painted or coated sheet applications where availability and cost are important | High-spec coated or uncoated sheet for processes that approach or exceed standard deep-drawing limits |
Selection rationale: - Choose DC04 where a balance of formability, strength, and cost is appropriate and where forming demands are high but within standard deep-drawing limits. - Choose DC05 where forming processes are at the limits (very high draw ratios, complex geometry, tight cosmetic requirements) and the process benefits from the tighter chemistry and cleaner microstructure.
9. Cost and Availability
- DC04: Widely available from many producers, offered in a range of gauges and coil widths, and typically priced competitively due to its broad use.
- DC05: Produced in more specialized runs; may incur a premium for tighter chemical control and enhanced surface/cleanliness specifications. Availability is good from major suppliers but may be more limited in some regional markets or in very large thickness ranges.
- Product forms: Both grades are commonly supplied as cold-rolled, annealed, and pickled sheet/coil; coated variants (electro-galvanized, hot-dip galvanized) are available from many manufacturers, often to order.
10. Summary and Recommendation
| Attribute | DC04 | DC05 |
|---|---|---|
| Weldability | Excellent (low CE) | Excellent (slightly better HAZ behavior in some cases) |
| Strength–Toughness trade-off | Moderate strength with good ductility | Slightly lower yield to prioritize ductility and drawability |
| Cost | Lower / more widely available | Higher / more specialized |
Recommendation: - Choose DC05 if your manufacturing process requires maximum uniform elongation and minimal springback for ultra-deep-drawing or highly complex stamped geometries, or if your application demands the most consistent formability and surface quality under extreme deformation. - Choose DC04 if you require excellent deep-drawing performance with somewhat higher availability and lower material cost, and where forming requirements are substantial but do not push the absolute limits of drawability.
Final note: Actual mechanical properties, chemical limits, and available surface treatments depend on the specific supplier’s product specification and the governing delivery standard (such as EN 10130). For critical applications, request mill certificates, perform trial forming, and consult the steelmaker’s datasheets to match grade, surface, and coating to the intended manufacturing process.