Q355NHC vs COR-TEN B – Composition, Heat Treatment, Properties, and Applications
Share
Table Of Content
Table Of Content
Introduction
Engineers, procurement managers, and manufacturing planners often face a choice between high-strength structural steels and weathering (atmospheric corrosion-resistant) steels. The decision commonly balances factors such as required load-bearing capacity and toughness versus long-term corrosion performance, lifecycle maintenance costs, and fabrication constraints (welding, forming, surface finishing). Q355NHC and COR-TEN B represent two different approaches: a microalloyed high-strength structural steel designed for consistent mechanical performance, and a weathering steel engineered to develop a protective surface patina that reduces the need for painting.
The principal technical distinction between these two grades is their alloying strategy and resulting surface behavior: one uses microalloying and controlled chemistry to raise strength and toughness (Q355NHC), while the other contains deliberate concentrations of weathering-promoting elements (Cu, Cr, P, and sometimes Ni) to foster a stable rust layer (COR-TEN B). That difference drives contrasts in corrosion resistance, fabrication practices, and typical applications.
1. Standards and Designations
- Q355NHC: Covered by Chinese standards such as GB/T 1591 series (Q355 family). Classified as a high-strength low-alloy structural steel (HSLA). Variants (Q355B, Q355C, Q355D, Q355N, Q355NH, Q355NC, Q355NHC) indicate differences in processing (normalized, thermomechanically rolled) and impact requirements.
- COR-TEN B: Commonly associated with weathering steels specified under North American and international practice, e.g., ASTM A242, ASTM A588 (similar concept), and historical proprietary COR-TEN specifications. Also related to EN 10025-5 designations for structural steel with improved atmospheric corrosion resistance. Classified as a low-alloy weathering steel (non-stainless).
Category summary: - Q355NHC: HSLA carbon/microalloy structural steel. - COR-TEN B: Low-alloy weathering carbon steel (atmospheric corrosion-resistant).
2. Chemical Composition and Alloying Strategy
The following table lists typical elemental composition ranges reported in standards and producer data sheets. Values vary with specification, mill practice, and thickness; the table shows representative ranges, not guaranteed guarantees — always check the purchase specification.
| Element | Q355NHC (typical range, wt%) | COR-TEN B (typical range, wt%) |
|---|---|---|
| C | 0.10 – 0.20 | ≤ 0.20 |
| Mn | 0.60 – 1.60 | 0.60 – 1.30 |
| Si | 0.10 – 0.50 | 0.10 – 0.50 |
| P | ≤ 0.025 (low) | 0.03 – 0.15 (elevated in some specs) |
| S | ≤ 0.035 | ≤ 0.035 |
| Cr | trace – 0.30 (sometimes none) | 0.30 – 0.65 |
| Ni | trace – 0.30 (sometimes none) | 0.15 – 0.65 |
| Mo | typically none (trace) | typically none |
| V | up to ~0.10 (microalloying) | trace |
| Nb (Cb) | up to ~0.05 (microalloying) | trace |
| Ti | trace (used in some melts) | trace |
| B | trace (controlled if present) | trace |
| N | controlled (low) | controlled (low) |
| Cu | usually low | 0.20 – 0.60 (key weathering element) |
How alloying affects behavior - Q355NHC: Microalloying elements (V, Nb, Ti), controlled carbon and nitrogen, and thermomechanical processing raise yield and tensile strength through grain refinement and precipitation strengthening while retaining good toughness. Low P and S improve toughness and weld quality. - COR-TEN B: Higher Cu, plus Cr, P, and sometimes Ni, promote formation of a dense, adherent oxide patina that slows further corrosion. These alloying elements are added specifically for atmospheric corrosion performance rather than to maximize strength.
3. Microstructure and Heat Treatment Response
Typical microstructures: - Q355NHC: Produced by thermomechanical rolling or controlled cooling with microalloying; microstructure is typically fine-grained ferrite with controlled amounts of pearlite and dispersed carbide/nitride precipitates (V-, Nb-, Ti-rich). Normalizing produces a refined ferrite-pearlite or bainitic texture depending on cooling rates and thickness. - COR-TEN B: Conventional hot-rolled ferrite-pearlite microstructure consistent with low-alloy carbon steels. No special microalloying is aimed at strengthening; microstructure focuses on stable chemistry for patina formation.
Heat treatment and processing effects: - Q355NHC responds well to normalization and thermomechanical control to improve toughness and consistency. Quenching and tempering is not a standard route for this structural grade but can be used for specific components; doing so transforms the microstructure and increases strength at the expense of cost. - COR-TEN B is typically supplied as hot-rolled plate without post-roll heat treatments aimed at strengthening. Normalizing is possible but usually unnecessary because its value proposition is corrosion resistance rather than maximum mechanical performance.
4. Mechanical Properties
Representative mechanical property comparison (typical ranges; verify against the project specification):
| Property | Q355NHC (typical) | COR-TEN B (typical) |
|---|---|---|
| Minimum Yield Strength (MPa) | ~355 (design intent of Q355 family) | ~345 (varies with standard and thickness) |
| Tensile Strength (MPa) | ~490 – 630 (depending on thickness and temper) | ~470 – 620 |
| Elongation (A5, %) | 18 – 24% (good ductility) | 16 – 22% |
| Impact Toughness (Charpy) | Controlled for low-temp grades; often specified ≥ 27 J at –20°C for NH variants | Variable; weathering steels can meet impact requirements but thicker sections or lower temps may require qualification |
| Hardness (HB) | Typical 140 – 200 HB (depending on processing) | Similar range for low-alloy plate |
Which is stronger/tougher/more ductile - Strength: Q355NHC is specified to deliver a reliable minimum yield of ~355 MPa and often benefits from microalloy strengthening and thermomechanical treatment; in many cases it provides superior guaranteed yield compared with some weathering steels. - Toughness and ductility: Q355NHC variants designed for impact performance (the "N" / "NH") tend to offer more predictable low-temperature toughness. COR-TEN B can show good toughness but must be selected and qualified by thickness and temperature if impact performance is critical.
5. Weldability
Weldability depends on carbon equivalent and microalloying.
Useful indices: - IIW carbon equivalent: $$CE_{IIW} = C + \frac{Mn}{6} + \frac{Cr+Mo+V}{5} + \frac{Ni+Cu}{15}$$ - International Pcm (sensitivity for HAZ cracking): $$P_{cm} = C + \frac{Si}{30} + \frac{Mn+Cu}{20} + \frac{Cr+Mo+V}{10} + \frac{Ni}{40} + \frac{Nb}{50} + \frac{Ti}{30} + \frac{B}{1000}$$
Interpretation (qualitative) - Q355NHC: Designed for good weldability — relatively low carbon and controlled microalloying minimize hardenability and cold cracking risk, provided proper preheat and welding procedures are used for thick sections. Microalloy elements in low concentrations do not greatly impair weldability but increase sensitivity to heat input control. - COR-TEN B: Alloying elements added for weathering (Cu, Cr, P, Ni) can raise CE slightly; welding is readily done with appropriate filler metals but the welded region will not develop the same patina or corrosion resistance as the parent material unless matched filler and post-weld treatments are used. Elevated P and localized hardenability can increase cracking risk if welding procedures are not controlled.
Practical guidance: use low-hydrogen consumables, control preheat/interpass temperature by thickness and CE/Pcm, and select fillers that either match mechanical properties and corrosion performance (for weathering steel) or that are recommended by the mill.
6. Corrosion and Surface Protection
- COR-TEN B (weathering steel): Designed to form a protective, adherent oxide layer (patina) in alternating wet/dry atmospheric conditions which reduces long-term uniform corrosion compared to plain carbon steel. This makes it attractive for unpainted façades, bridges, and outdoor sculptures. Note: COR-TEN performance depends on environment — it is not appropriate for continuously wet, marine chloride-rich, or highly polluted atmospheres without additional protection.
- Q355NHC: Not a weathering steel. Requires conventional corrosion protection: painting/coatings, galvanizing, or cathodic protection depending on exposure. For many structural applications the lower initial material cost plus standard coatings are preferred.
When stainless-style indices do not apply - PREN (pitting resistance equivalent number) is used for stainless alloys and is not applicable to these non-stainless steels. For completeness, PREN formula is: $$\text{PREN} = \text{Cr} + 3.3 \times \text{Mo} + 16 \times \text{N}$$ but it is not used for Q355NHC or COR-TEN B.
7. Fabrication, Machinability, and Formability
- Cutting and machining: Both grades machine similarly to common structural steels; microalloyed Q355NHC may exhibit slightly higher tool wear than plain low-carbon steels due to stronger matrix and precipitates. Use appropriate speeds and tooling.
- Forming and bending: Q355NHC typically offers better controlled forming because of consistent yield behavior and ductility. COR-TEN B is formable but bending to tight radii may crack if the material is very thick or if the forming temperature is low; tests or manufacturer guidance are recommended.
- Finishing: COR-TEN surfaces will oxidize over time; welding, grinding, or surface treatments will alter visual appearance. Q355NHC expects coating or galvanizing for long-term corrosion protection.
8. Typical Applications
| Q355NHC (HSLA) Uses | COR-TEN B (Weathering Steel) Uses |
|---|---|
| Heavy structural components, beams, columns, welded frames where certified yield and toughness are required | Architectural façades, bridges, outdoor sculptures and cladding where long-term unpainted appearance and reduced maintenance are desired |
| Crane rails, lifting frames, machinery bases, pressure-retaining supports (where proper spec'd) | Highway and pedestrian bridges (in suitable climates), signage, containers exposed to air-dry cycles |
| Fabricated welded structures requiring controlled toughness and weld procedures | Decorative or exposed structures where patina aesthetics and reduced coating maintenance are priorities |
Selection rationale: choose Q355NHC when guaranteed mechanical properties, weldability for thick sections, and predictable toughness are primary. Choose COR-TEN B when atmospheric corrosion performance and reduced coating maintenance offset any premium and when the environmental conditions suit patina formation.
9. Cost and Availability
- Q355NHC: Widely produced in plate and coil sizes in regions using GB/T standards; cost is typically competitive for structural steel and may be lower than specialty weathering grades. Availability is good in markets served by major steel mills that supply HSLA plates.
- COR-TEN B: Often priced higher than plain carbon plate due to alloying additions and market position as a specialty weathering steel. Availability depends on regional demand; common in architectural and bridge markets but lead times may be longer for large plate orders or unusual thicknesses.
Economics: include life-cycle costs — COR-TEN B can reduce painting and maintenance costs in appropriate environments, which may compensate for higher initial material cost.
10. Summary and Recommendation
Summary table (qualitative)
| Criterion | Q355NHC | COR-TEN B |
|---|---|---|
| Weldability | Good — designed for structural welding with standard procedures | Good with care — welds require matched filler and attention to patina loss |
| Strength–Toughness | High and consistent (HSLA microalloying) | Moderate-to-high; toughness variable with thickness |
| Corrosion resistance (as-supplied) | Requires coating/galvanizing | Superior in suitable atmospheric conditions (forms patina) |
| Cost | Lower material cost in many markets | Higher material cost but potential lifecycle savings |
| Availability | Broad for structural plate/coil | Common but region-dependent; lead times can vary |
Conclude with guidance - Choose Q355NHC if you need a reliably high-yield structural steel with controlled toughness, good weldability for heavy welded fabrications, and will use conventional coatings or galvanizing for corrosion protection. - Choose COR-TEN B if you need atmospheric corrosion resistance without regular repainting, desire the weathered aesthetic, and your service environment favors patina formation (not continuously wet, marine splash, or aggressive chloride environments).
Final note: Always verify the exact chemical and mechanical requirements in the project specification and consult mill certificates. For welded, plated, or exposed applications, run joint design, filler metal selection, and mock-ups to confirm corrosion performance, weld behavior, and final appearance before large-scale procurement or fabrication.