Q345B vs Q345D – Composition, Heat Treatment, Properties, and Applications
Share
Table Of Content
Table Of Content
Introduction
Q345B and Q345D are two temper/grade variants of the Chinese low-alloy structural steel family commonly referenced under GB/T 1591. Engineers, procurement managers, and manufacturing planners frequently weigh them against each other when designing welded structures, bridges, cranes, and cold-climate equipment. The typical decision context balances required mechanical strength, weldability, production cost, and required impact toughness at the service temperature.
The principal practical distinction between these two grades lies in their specified performance at lower temperatures: one is intended for general structural use at ambient conditions, while the other is specified and processed to deliver higher fracture toughness at reduced (sub-ambient) temperatures. Because many other chemical and mechanical parameters are shared (or very similar), the selection often turns on low-temperature toughness requirements, fabrication constraints, and budget.
1. Standards and Designations
- Primary standard: GB/T 1591 — “Hot-rolled low alloy structural steel” (China).
- International equivalents / related specifications: there is no direct one-to-one match in ASTM/ASME or EN; similar high-strength low-alloy (HSLA) steels exist (for example ASTM A572, S355 families) but differences in chemistry and impact criteria exist.
- Classification by type: HSLA (high-strength low-alloy) carbon structural steel.
- Designations:
- Q345B — Q = yield point, 345 ≈ 345 MPa minimum yield, “B” indicates a particular impact-test temperature class (typically 0 °C).
- Q345D — same nominal strength class with “D” indicating a stricter (lower temperature) impact-test requirement (typically −20 °C).
2. Chemical Composition and Alloying Strategy
Below is a compact comparison of the common elements typically controlled for Q345 grades. Values shown are representative typical limits used in practice (consult the applicable edition of GB/T 1591 or the mill certificate for exact limits).
| Element | Typical range or limit (Q345B) | Typical range or limit (Q345D) | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| C (carbon) | ≤ ~0.20 wt% | ≤ ~0.20 wt% (often on the lower side) | Lower C improves weldability and toughness; D may be produced with slightly tighter C control. |
| Mn (manganese) | ~0.4–1.6 wt% | ~0.4–1.6 wt% | Mn increases strength and hardenability; typical content similar for both. |
| Si (silicon) | ≤ ~0.50 wt% | ≤ ~0.50 wt% | Deoxidation; modest amounts assist strength without harming toughness. |
| P (phosphorus) | ≤ 0.035 wt% | ≤ 0.035 wt% | Kept low to avoid embrittlement. |
| S (sulfur) | ≤ 0.035 wt% | ≤ 0.035 wt% | Kept low for toughness and weldability. |
| Cr, Ni, Mo, V, Nb, Ti, B, N | Generally in trace amounts or not specified beyond max limits | Same, with D sometimes having tighter microalloy additions or grain refinement control | Microalloying (Nb, V, Ti) and controlled processing are used to refine grain and improve low-temperature toughness for D. |
How the alloying strategy works: - Carbon and manganese are primary strength contributors; higher Mn increases strength but elevates hardenability and potential for cold cracking if not controlled. - Microalloying (Nb, V, Ti) can be added in small amounts to promote grain refinement and precipitation strengthening without substantial increases in carbon equivalent — a favorable route to improve low-temperature impact toughness. - Controlling tramp elements P and S is critical for both grades; lower levels help maintain ductility and fracture resistance.
(Always verify the mill certificate or the governing standard edition for the exact composition for a specific heat or product form.)
3. Microstructure and Heat Treatment Response
Typical microstructure: - Both Q345B and Q345D are produced to deliver a predominantly ferrite–pearlite microstructure in the as-rolled condition. The microstructure is a function of chemistry, cooling rate, and thermo-mechanical processing.
Processing routes and their effects: - Normalizing: Heating above transformation temperature and air cooling produces a refined, more homogeneous ferrite–pearlite structure that can slightly improve toughness. - Controlled rolling / Thermo-Mechanical Control Processing (TMCP): Reduces austenite grain size before transformation and promotes fine-grained ferrite with dispersed pearlite or bainite — this is a common route to meet Q345D low-temperature impact requirements without increasing alloying. - Quenching & tempering: Not typical for these grades because Q345 is specified as hot-rolled structural steel; quench–temper would create higher strength but is a different product class. - Heat treatment response differences: Because the base chemistry is similar, differences in response are usually achieved by tighter control of rolling schedules and microalloy additions for Q345D to assure a finer grain size and higher Charpy V-notch energy at low temperature.
Grain size and toughness: - Finer prior-austenite grain size and reduced inclusion size/distribution improve toughness and reduce ductile-to-brittle transition temperature — the usual mechanism by which Q345D outperforms Q345B at subambient temperatures.
4. Mechanical Properties
Representative mechanical properties for Q345 grades (typical values; verify the standard or mill test certificate for the exact product):
| Property | Typical Q345B | Typical Q345D | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Minimum Yield Strength (MPa) | ~345 MPa | ~345 MPa | Both grades target the same minimum yield (name gives 345 MPa). |
| Tensile Strength (MPa) | ~470–630 MPa | ~470–630 MPa | Overlapping tensile ranges; specific product form (plate, coil) and thickness affect values. |
| Elongation (A%) | ≥ ~20% (depending on thickness) | ≥ ~20% (depending on thickness) | D generally maintains similar ductility while improving toughness. |
| Impact Toughness (Charpy V) | Usually specified at 0 °C (e.g., 27 J typical) | Specified at lower temperature, e.g., −20 °C (same energy level at lower temp) | The key differentiator: Q345D requires acceptable impact energy at a lower temperature. |
| Hardness (HB) | Typically moderate; not a hardness-controlled grade | Similar | Hardness is usually within ranges compatible with welding and forming; not a primary spec control. |
Interpretation: - Strength: Both grades provide the same nominal yield and similar tensile ranges—neither is inherently “stronger” in static strength if supplied to the same specification. - Toughness: Q345D is processed and qualified to deliver higher impact toughness at lower temperatures; therefore it is less likely to experience brittle fracture in cold environments. - Ductility: Comparable between the two when tested at their respective qualification temperatures; toughening strategies aim to retain ductility in Q345D.
5. Weldability
Weldability is largely governed by carbon content, carbon-equivalent (hardenability), and microalloying.
Common weldability formulas (useful for qualitative comparison): $$CE_{IIW} = C + \frac{Mn}{6} + \frac{Cr+Mo+V}{5} + \frac{Ni+Cu}{15}$$ and $$P_{cm} = C + \frac{Si}{30} + \frac{Mn+Cu}{20} + \frac{Cr+Mo+V}{10} + \frac{Ni}{40} + \frac{Nb}{50} + \frac{Ti}{30} + \frac{B}{1000}$$
Qualitative interpretation: - Both Q345B and Q345D have relatively low carbon and moderate Mn, which generally confers good weldability for structural applications. - Q345D may be produced with slightly tighter control of C and with optimized microalloying/grain size to meet low-temperature toughness, which can actually aid post-weld toughness if weld procedures control heat input and preheat requirements. - Carbon-equivalent values for both grades are typically low-to-moderate, implying standard preheat/postheat procedures and common welding consumables suffice in most cases; however, thicker sections, restraint, and joint design can necessitate preheating and controlled heat input. - Always derive PWHT (post-weld heat treatment) and preheat recommendations from a weld procedure qualification that uses the actual CE or $P_{cm}$ for the heat.
6. Corrosion and Surface Protection
- Neither Q345B nor Q345D is stainless; both are non-stainless low-alloy structural steels and will corrode in aggressive environments.
- Typical protection strategies: hot-dip galvanizing, zinc or epoxy painting systems, weathering coatings (if alloy composition supports it), cathodic protection in immersed environments, or using sacrificial coatings.
- For stainless or corrosion-resistant index usage: PREN is not applicable for these non-stainless steels. Reminder of PREN formula for stainless contexts: $$\text{PREN} = \text{Cr} + 3.3 \times \text{Mo} + 16 \times \text{N}$$
- In practice, choose surface protection according to exposure class (atmospheric, marine, chemical) rather than small compositional differences between Q345B and Q345D.
7. Fabrication, Machinability, and Formability
- Formability: Both grades exhibit good cold-forming and bending characteristics typical of HSLA steels when within specified thicknesses and when bend radii meet recommended minima. Q345D’s enhanced low-temperature toughness does not materially degrade formability.
- Machinability: Both are moderate in machinability—material condition (microalloying, strength level) affects tool life. Typical machining precautions for higher-strength steels (use of rigid setups, adequate coolant, and proper cutting parameters) apply.
- Cutting and welding: Standard oxy-fuel, plasma, and laser cutting work similarly for both. Welding consumables are selected to match mechanical property requirements; when impact toughness at low temperature is required in the weld zone, use matching consumables and qualified procedures.
8. Typical Applications
| Q345B (typical uses) | Q345D (typical uses) |
|---|---|
| General structural members: beams, columns, welded plate girders for standard climates | Structural members for cold climates: offshore topsides, refrigerated storage frames, cold-region bridges |
| Cranes, hoists, and general fabrication where ambient or slightly subambient service applies | Components exposed to lower ambient or transient subzero temperatures, or where fracture toughness at −20 °C is required |
| Machinery frames, fabrication steel, general-purpose plate | Heavy welded steelwork with low-temperature service criteria, certain pressure equipment where low-temp toughness is specified |
| Pipe fittings and flanges for non-corrosive service | Same as Q345B where additional low-temperature impact performance is mandated |
Selection rationale: - Choose Q345B for cost-sensitive projects operating at or above standard ambient service temperatures. - Choose Q345D where codes, client specifications, or risk assessments demand validated impact toughness at moderately low temperatures (e.g., −20 °C).
9. Cost and Availability
- Cost: Q345B is generally slightly less expensive than Q345D because D typically requires tighter process control or additional testing to validate low-temperature toughness. The price delta is modest for most commodity plate/coils but can rise with thickness and tight delivery times.
- Availability: Q345B is widely produced and available in many product forms (plate, coil, beam). Q345D is also commonly available but may have longer lead times or be produced to order in some mills, especially for thicker sections or when specific mill heat treatments are required.
- Product form impacts supply: plates and structural shapes in common sizes are readily available; specialized dimensions, heavy plate thicknesses, or unusual surface tolerances can lengthen lead times.
10. Summary and Recommendation
Summary table
| Attribute | Q345B | Q345D |
|---|---|---|
| Weldability | Very good (low C, moderate CE) | Very good; may need same welding controls; often similar or slightly better PWHT behavior due to process control |
| Strength–Toughness balance | Good general balance at ambient temperatures | Better low-temperature toughness for comparable strength |
| Cost | Lower (typical) | Slightly higher (typical) |
Recommendations: - Choose Q345B if the structure will operate primarily at ambient or mildly cold temperatures, cost control is important, and standard welding/fabrication procedures are to be used. - Choose Q345D if the application exposes material to sustained sub-zero or cold-shock environments, the design or code requires verified impact energy at lower temperatures (for example −20 °C), or if risk assessment points to brittle-fracture control at lower service temperatures.
Final note: Both Q345B and Q345D are effective HSLA structural steels with the same nominal yield strength. The practical distinguishing factor is validated low-temperature toughness and the processing controls used to achieve it. Always specify required impact temperature and energy values explicitly in purchase documents, and request mill test certificates and Charpy V-notch results for the delivered heats to ensure the selected grade meets the project’s fracture-toughness and fabrication needs.